I've had a 172 previously. I loved that car, but after a while and doing 70 miles a day in it the rattles, poor build quality, loooud exhaust and hard ride (coilovers) got a bit tedious.
In an ideal world I'd still have it, but use it for weekend blasts and track days. But couldn't afford that.
I wanted something well made, big engine, nice sound (not too loud) and bit more of a cruiser.
I wouldn't expect everyone on a clio forum to be a fan of Golfs anyway to be honest. But I've always liked them, and fits the bill for what I want and need.