I have never really had a go with a Humax, so don't really know have good they are?.
I love my Topfield TF5800 though
. It does everything I want and more... Had it just over a year and never really hooked it up to the PC & the other day decided to hook it up. Managed to update the firmware, download music to it
& transfer my programmes to & from my PC to burn to DVD for my Brother
. You can now record via the web or by sending a text message lol
.
I also have mine in my bedroom & I record through the night, day & then leave it recording while I go to sleep. You can sometimes hear the HD spinning, but its not that loud as there's no fan or anything.