Purists will say it's not as good, fly by wire throttle, slightly heavier etc etc
But for 2k, with FSH, belts and low miles it certainly sounds like a good buy therefore does the small difference matter? (Though I see you're the other end of the country so I've not much of an idea what this sort of car would go for near you)
You may spend more money on a Ph 2 (Ph 1 comes with 15s for example) and more time on a non-cup (more time stripping, but then again stripping is free...)