Alternative throttle valve for Clio III RS?

[Oliver_K4M]

Hi,
can anybody tell me if the the BMW throttle valves used in the N46-B20 engines are compatible in terms of electrical behaviour with the throttle valve that is used by Renault Sport in Clio II RS Ph.2+3, Clio III RS and the Twingo II RS (8200110998)? Mechanically it seems to fit.

source: http://www.vdo.com/media/182586/flc_engine_actuators_en.pdf

Some more pictures
BMW:


Renault:


The reason why I ask is, that the bmw TBs are much cheaper to get and they are availible with the same PCD but larger throttle dia, e.g. 408-238-425-005Z (64mm).

Thanks.

 

[bloke]

you don't need bigger body though.

 

[Oliver_K4M]

Increasing the diameter was only a "side idea"....
...basically i want to know if BMW 60mm is compatible to Renault 60mm?

 

[bloke]

wouldn't surprise me if it worked. grab one and try.