ClioSport.net

Register a free account today to become a member!
Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read more here.

Best non sport for the missus??



Dan

  172 track thingy
my missus is due to start driving again as she has a new job so she has started looking at clios as an option :)

(and no there wont be any pictures of the missus lol)

but she doesnt want a sport (or anything over a 1.4 tbh) as she's not arsed about pace she just wants it to look nice and be able make it her own a little.

the thing is she has a nice 2-2.5K budget to spend on a PH2 shape clio but what engine and options is best to go for?

she will be doing about 20-30 miles per day (everyday of the week at times) and then maybe the odd long trips too.

i have said about the 1.2 16V in various options being good little runners with nice bits inside but i also hear the DCi clios aint bad but know less about them tbh :S

could anyone point me in the right direction for whats best to go for?

thanks
Dan
 

Martin_172

ClioSport Club Member
DCi's are awesome however they are getting on a bit and the last thing you want is for it to break and let your mrs down. this is why i bought my mrs a 1.6 16v Dynamique.

i bought it as her first car, and after she got a 1.2 16v curtisy car when her car went in for warranty work she said shes glad we got her it, she would hate to drive a 1.2! and she doesnt drive quick thats why it benefits her, plenty low down torque for around town. it does 38mpg which i always slate but the more i think about it its probably not bad for a mid sized petrol engine!

plus its a good solid engine, never gave us any issues, and being a petrol if it does brake down i can sort it unlike the diesels!


EDIT: also forgot to add, go for Dynamique trim but look about there is gems to be had, we found ours, 1.6 16v VVT dynamique with Climate control, cabasse stereo, 6 disc changer, cruise control. was on 45k on a 54 plate at the time we paid £3800 at a dealer which was good at the time (2years ago)

good spec cars do pop up and make it easier come selling time to shift on
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
ye i did say about the 1.6 but she doesnt want to pay the extra insurance :S what about the 1.4??
 

Joe#

ClioSport Club Member
Buy mine next year ?;)

To be honest though mate, the dci's are very good value for money. Cheaper tax also, not sure about the insurance though?
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
Buy mine next year ?;)

To be honest though mate, the dci's are very good value for money. Cheaper tax also, not sure about the insurance though?

i was waiting for you to say that tbh ;)

is it coming up for sale around feb,march, april time?? and does it have a CD player which i have been told is high up the list with alloy wheels lol (i know u have them :))
 
  Edition 30
The 1.6 is a good upgrade from a 1.1/1.2 if insurance is too much on the sport.

Mine is THIRSTY though.

I do a lot of town driving and rarely see above 35mpg.

Dci would be my suggestion but I don't know a lot about them either.
 

Joe#

ClioSport Club Member
Lol. It's got a cd player in (Sony one at the moment, but standard will be going back into).

The dynamics have much better interior IMO. Nicer seats etc etc.

My birthday is at the end of march so it should be up for sale then, or the start of April if everything goes to plan.

DCI 80/100 is what I would get if I could rewind time :)
 

aucky

ClioSport Club Member
DCi 65 if you can find a good'un, although the low running costs come with higher repair prices, and not really necessary for that mileage.
Better than the 1.2 petrol engine though.
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
any common faults on a DCi to look out for?? and anything that is worth looking for on a DCi apart from the basic good service history??
 

Knuckles

ClioSport Admin
get the 1.5 dci 100 if theres one available... if not, the 1.4 16v is a decent little engine... plenty of power for what she'll need, big step up from a 1.2 and as said, there will be a few about with decent options... mine has the 'chill pack' which i had no idea about untill i bought it lol A/C and electric sunroof :cool:
 
i had a MK3 05-09 dynamique s 1.5 DCI 86 for my first car and it was a great car plenty of kit on it and just the added benefit of the torque and turbo but also the MPG was brilliant and she would barely have to fill up if she doesn't drive like a maniac, but the PH2 DCI 80 would be my choice with that budget,
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
cool i think i will look for a DCi 80 then :)

i have seen a few with turbo problems though :S is that a common issue??
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
wouldn't say there are any 'common' issues with the clio DCI engines

thats alright then :)

i know the basic stuff to look for on clios as the faults mostly go through the entire range but never delt with a DCi tbh.
i used to have a 1.9D MK1 but im guessing thats totally different right??
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
thats alright then :)

i know the basic stuff to look for on clios as the faults mostly go through the entire range but never delt with a DCi tbh.
i used to have a 1.9D MK1 but im guessing thats totally different right??

engine setup wise??
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
1.2 16v. never had a problem with mine. around 43mpg and i dont exactly drive like bill oddie.

i think the DCi 80 is high up the list with the 1.4 16V being 2nd choice atm, but i think its gonna be down to the best deal at the time now as they all seem quite good at what they do :)
 
DCi's are awesome however they are getting on a bit and the last thing you want is for it to break and let your mrs down. this is why i bought my mrs a 1.6 16v Dynamique.

i bought it as her first car, and after she got a 1.2 16v curtisy car when her car went in for warranty work she said shes glad we got her it, she would hate to drive a 1.2! and she doesnt drive quick thats why it benefits her, plenty low down torque for around town. it does 38mpg which i always slate but the more i think about it its probably not bad for a mid sized petrol engine!

plus its a good solid engine, never gave us any issues, and being a petrol if it does brake down i can sort it unlike the diesels!
Just a few point is the dci's are getting on and they sold them almosyt the whole time the cars was in production then surly petrols are just as old?
Just one thing to remmeber the petrols are all older in design the diesel 1.5 was brought out after the phase 2 range was released. Age has no bearing on reliability though. Trying to say a petrol is more reliable is unfair and unjustified.

If she likes low down torque and mpg then without question the dci is the one to get. The 1.6 would seem wasted.

Regards fixability there less to go wrong no coils packs no spark plugs. Yes it has a turbo but they arn't an issue realy.
 
cool i think i will look for a DCi 80 then :)

i have seen a few with turbo problems though :S is that a common issue??
Nope not realy so long as you take care and service there no issue.

Sure some have had issues but rebuild turbo's arn't that much.
 
get the 1.5 dci 100 if theres one available... if not, the 1.4 16v is a decent little engine... plenty of power for what she'll need, big step up from a 1.2 and as said, there will be a few about with decent options... mine has the 'chill pack' which i had no idea about untill i bought it lol A/C and electric sunroof :cool:
IMO the 100 isn't a great buy anyway the gearbox is terribale and if you want low down torque it doesn't provide it. The turbo was all top end boost to get the hp figure.

1.2 is a fine engine realy no reason realy to get anyhting more unless it costs no more.
 

Bluebeard

ClioSport Moderator
  Whichever has fuel
if it was my money i'd buy either a 1.5dci 65 or a 1.4 petrol. The 1.2 16v (while it has more bhp than the dci) is dangerous on a motorway nowadays. Not enough torque.

Out of the two it would soley depend on the car itself. Service history/spec/condition etc.
 
  275 Trophy
Have you looked at the Meganes? My misses wanted to upgrade from a awful VW Lupo and she is now over the moon with her 54 plate 1.6 petrol Megane Dynamique, 44k miles FSH £2.4k.

You seem to get a lot more car for your money, and the engines are similar - you can get the 1.4 petrol (not the 1.2 though). Insurance cheaper than 1 litre Lupo as well (for her at least).
 

RDH

ClioSport Club Member
1.2 is easily sufficient enough, cheapest to buy, maintain and probably run. At the end of the day the motorway speed limit is 70, which it will do with ease.

I had mine for 3 years and loved it. Fair enough there are more powerful options but if you want power then get a sport.
 

Bluebeard

ClioSport Moderator
  Whichever has fuel
1.2 is easily sufficient enough, cheapest to buy, maintain and probably run. At the end of the day the motorway speed limit is 70, which it will do with ease.

I had mine for 3 years and loved it. Fair enough there are more powerful options but if you want power then get a sport.

Doing 70 is not really the issue.

Its doing 65mph and needing to pull out to overtake without causing lorry-like tailbacks.

The reason this is on my brain is because about 4 weeks ago I went to brighton in a dci 65. then exactly one week later I did the same trip in a 1.2 16v clio and wanted to set fire to it less than one hour into the journey.
 

Chris205

ClioSport Club Member
  Many Things
I'd certainly get her a DCi 80 if I were you mate, the girlfriend has a mapped dci 65 and its a great little car, 65mpg + and £30 a year road tax. Hers may be for sale in the not too distant future, as I say its been remapped, its black, coilovers, 182 cup packed wheels, spacers, 182 interior and Omp Steering wheel. Let me know if you're interested
 

RDH

ClioSport Club Member
I see what your getting at. I'm basing my opinion on the fact I had one for 3 years, and theres no doubting there is a lack of power for motorways, but you just take it into consideration and drive accordingly. Also the fact I've got a 75 bhp Transit Connect which sometimes is loaded up with easily 300kgs of gear, and is almost certainly the slowest thing on this earth, does 50 miles a day up and down the motorway no problem.

And to be fair if the OP is going to be doing alot of motorway miles, then he shouldn't be looking at clios.
 
any common faults on a DCi to look out for?? and anything that is worth looking for on a DCi apart from the basic good service history??

Its a work in progress but someone was asking about buying one so I wrote this up. Needs expanding if anyone has any bit to add please do.

I'm gonna try write a few mopre on 1.2/2.0(might do one per model type)/3.0


Things to looks out for when buying a dci Clio

Whilst this is a bit extensive it should cover most possible issues.

Engine

Check the car starts first time without hesitation or warning lights comming on. Always leve the car a few seconds before starting for the coil warning lights etc to go off before starting the engine though.

Check the car idles right the only exceptions can be with low voltage or the air con is switched on as this can up the idle from the 850rpm which it should stay dead on at to upto about 950rpm.

The stock battery is 600A most motorfactories will check it for condition if you ask nicly.

The engine you have to remember is computer control very little can be fiddled by the owner little diagnostics can be done it will if a problem exists almsot certainly need a dealership to check with there computer to fault find.

Things to check though check oil/water levels. Head gasgets arn't an issue there strong. But they can burn oil so need to ensure if they do burn a bit that with the 18k service intervals that it is checked. No need to worry if it does burn a little oil its just that if it burn 1 liter per 6k (renault toleracne allows for 1 per 600 miles) then after 18k you might have been running below the minimum if the oil level sensor etc isn't working.

Driveshafts need checking there quite prown to problems get the car on full lock and check or else get under the car and try shake the driveshafts to see if there any play in them at either ends.

Check again as with any car for damage wisbones and stearing rack for damage also any subframe damage.

Check to ensure the car goes into all gear as well as any Renault gearbox can and check it doens't move around to much or drop out of 5th (can be a show of low gearbox oil level or worn bodbone mount (the common to wear a lot one)

Check the car stears and brakes stright get it on a stright road and brake hard make sure the car doesn't drift (take note the car is bound to drift a bit to the left on a cambered road.

Check the engine pulls to the redline (5k) it not amazing over 4k but it should in second get to the limiter easily regardless of engine hp moel. Check it pulls from 1.5kl admitidly it doens't realy get the turbo to full boost till 2k but it might show a problem if it jerky etc

Listen out for any whistling from the turbo on spool up there always a bit thoug. Idealy once you've heard a few you'll know what normal any excessive whistling can point to a faulty turbo which is quite common and if it does fail the engine burns it own oil and goes into manic mode you have to stop it with the brakes and gears and stall it else within a few minutes of buring its own oil the engine will be sort of scrap as it will have run itself dry bearing wise etc. However having leaves etc stuck in the intake can do exactly the same thing if they get stuck near the filter.

The problem is due to the oil lines and the long service intervals. If change the oil more (than the 18k original service rules) often and if your aware then if it does fail you know to stall the engine fast. Its a cheap and good mantainince practice which can be done in 20 mins so always worthwhile.

One problem with the engine is the fact that if the engine cambelt or somehting does snap or it goes burn its own oil is breakers yard know the value of the engines so prices can be about 50% more for an engine or gearbox.

The gearbox on the 80 and 65 are much the same there similar to the 172/182 ones the 80 one being the same type the 65 being a slightly weeker one.

(Basically the Willaims, dci 80 and 172/172 share the same type box. The Valver, 1.6 16V and DCi 65 share the same type.

Check to see if there any excessive smoke at full throttle they shoulnd't bee any but a blocked EGR valve is common cause and easy to clean also it will mean the engine can be jerky so if you want use it as a bartering point and risk it being the easy to fix EGR.

Fuel economy is often a big reason for buying one so check 30mpg is nearly impossible except for hard track day work 50mpg is hard driving on a long rung 65mpg is possible if you r taking care. Over 70 can be done depends on your dedication.

Depending one spec levels check the auto lights and if possible wipers although failure of them isn't a huge concert turning lights/wiper on isn't hard can just be dud sensor.

Same goes for the whole of the cars wiring realty check the lights (normal beam lights can go a lot and ofen you never notice)

Check the wear on the drivers seat and pedals if your taking car getting ina nd out and driving no wear should ver realy be evident wear on the side of the pedal often indicated to a bit of harder driving toe and heal etc.

The common problems with the dci can include glow plus failing and TDC sensor. TDC ensor often shows up in poor stating gloew plugs are difficult paret form the glow wanring light ofnten being trouble but the car often sarts fine with just one glow plug. They’re only cheap to fix though.

Check the clutch it should be the regular heavy clutch and have a high biting point it should never slip or give any hastle unless its worn which shouldn't occure till over 100k at least regardless of driving unless its a real hard driven town car (in which can 100k takes a while to do).

Check for towing hooks and any indication under the car that it might have been towing there rated to 900KG from emeory which is a lot particualy if you load the car up so the clutch etc can take a battering if they have been driven that loaded up.

Check the cambelt has been done or be aware it needs to be done idealy if you have no warently ar 60k/4 years IMO but 72k and 5 years is what Renault were happy to warently it at. Its a quick job to do make sure if your using a none Renault dealerhsip they have the tools and know what there doing snce the pump needs tobe pinned as well when chnage the belt. Its about 2 hours work to do the belt if there taking there time and the kits under £70 from memory. So expect a bill of £150 to £300 for the work.

Brake pads are cheap if they need doing and since there so over rated (designed for a 150hp car) they shouldn't wear very quickly. Expect 18k minimum for a life anyting less thans that shows a very very hard driven car or a problem with sticking calipers etc. Rear drums will last seemigly forever and recient chnages to the service rulesmeans they should be cleaned every service. So check to see how worn they are there a cheap part but oftne show the way the car is driven 100k is easily to do even on a car which is quite hard driven. The only exception can be if the rivets, which hold them together famously as they can, do fail requiring new drums.

Wheel bearings can as wirth all cars fail but they are good and strong 100k should be easily possible front and rear.

Shock life well depends on user and what your happy with.

The dci has the stiuffest anti roll bar ever fitted to the none RS models (its infact thicker than the RS models but they use a different design0 this is to help combat the weight of the engine over the smaller engine models so the roll should be less than 1.2/14. models (1.6 16V use the same anti roll bar) links on the bottom of them to the wishbones can fail in use difficult to sence often but you'll hear a knocking sound on cornering.

Tyre wear should be nice and even unless something liek ahrd cornering has been done (side wall wear in extreme cases) or if the r has seena lot of speeds bump it can wear the inside of the tyre.

Stock Dynamic tyres are 185/55/15 and whilst there cheap 195/50 are cheaper there only disadvantageis the speedo under reads by an extra 2% or so ie your milage is 2% out but there often a few % out anyway. Also it will catch with stock wheels on the rear arch liner so idealy should rmeove the wheel and cut away the one bolt which can rub on the wheel a bit.

If the car has aircon/climate then check it works.

Point to check on a dci 80 (the give away is the blue I on the side badges)

Check the intercooler at the front of the car for damage there not cheap to buy and can pick up stone damage etc easily.

Check for a under floor front cover it helps to protect the engine from damage form the road debree etc and should be there.

Also check the engine cover is on under the bonnet it helps with noise.

Brakes are quite touchy so they shouldn't have any spongyness or massivly heavy weighing if they do can be a fault vacume pump or in the case of spongness just need bleeding.

Sunroofs rattle its just there way IMO leave it if its out of warently otherwise get it back and get them to do the next level of repair that they can. You can hold the sunroof down more with sponge etc on the handle but IMO don't bother it just puts extra loads on it.

Check the seats slide and one 3 door the seats can and do slide and fold forward to get into the back.

Check the fog lights work as the connectors are a bit rubish.

Cop[ied from here http://www.cliosport.net/forum/showthread.php?235704-DCI-buyers-guide-FAQ&highlight=dci
 

Ricardos

ClioSport Club Member
  LY 200 EDC
The missus has a 1.4 16V 54 plate Dynamique, i borrow it every now and then and it's spot on.

Heated wing wirrors
Xenon headlights
Auto wipers and headlights

Previous owner fitted an RS upper grill, RS gearknob insert and RS dash strips. A tidy car and nice to drive, apart from servicing there hasn't been a problem with it in the 18 months i've been with her.
 

Martin_172

ClioSport Club Member
Just a few point is the dci's are getting on and they sold them almosyt the whole time the cars was in production then surly petrols are just as old?
Just one thing to remmeber the petrols are all older in design the diesel 1.5 was brought out after the phase 2 range was released. Age has no bearing on reliability though. Trying to say a petrol is more reliable is unfair and unjustified.

If she likes low down torque and mpg then without question the dci is the one to get. The 1.6 would seem wasted.

Regards fixability there less to go wrong no coils packs no spark plugs. Yes it has a turbo but they arn't an issue realy.

edde, if i had a maximum budget of 2500 to spend on a car for my mrs who wasnt doing mega miles, i wouldnt be buying a DCi. as people on here know ive had 3 dci's now, and never been let down once, but ive also saw the bills of people who have been let down.

i dont fancy spending my mrs money on something that can easily cost the same as her budget to put right

less to go wrong? what planet are you on? i certainly wouldnt be buying a car because it has no spark plugs.

going brand new i would never in a million years pick a 1.6 16v over a dci. but when going 5-10 years old. give me the petrol every day over the common rail diesel (as i said were talking about for our mrs here, if it was my car i would go for the diesel as the potental cost doesnt really bother me as im in a position to put right)
 

Martin_172

ClioSport Club Member
ye i did say about the 1.6 but she doesnt want to pay the extra insurance :S what about the 1.4??

they are pretty similar engines, we found the insurance was much the same so it made sence to go with the 1.6 for the extra 10hp and bit more torque, but do a quote to make sure your the same
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
Thanks guys it's all mixing me up now lol

I think 1.4 16V in a nice colour would do her fine tbh but the DCi just seems a little more user friendly (until it breaks of course lol)

Hard choice but there's a while to have a look round 1st before jumping the gun :)
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
they are pretty similar engines, we found the insurance was much the same so it made sence to go with the 1.6 for the extra 10hp and bit more torque, but do a quote to make sure your the same

Ye I will get her to quote them then :)

And the only thing that makes a diff is she lives in an LL post code area (Wrexham) which seems to rape everyone on insurance :S
 

Martin_172

ClioSport Club Member
ahh not ideal. worth a try though.

as i said above im mr dci, i swear by them but if a fuel pump fails you can be £500-£1000 doing it on the cheap to fix! that compaired to a coil pack or something on the petrol at £40-£50 is a big difference. this wudnt put me off if it was my car as they are pretty reliable (says me with the 10 month old dci awaiting a recovery to the dealers lol) but if it was my mrs cash i would want something that was going to be solid and cheap to run with repairs etc, and i dont mind giving up 15-20mpg for the sake of no big nasty bills. especially when my mrs only does a few hundred miles a month!
 

Dan

  172 track thingy
Ye that's it I think you have sorted out this issue for me then lol a 1.4/1.6 petrol is what we will look for :)
 


Top