ClioSport.net

Register a free account today to become a member!
Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read more here.

Top Gear Survey (Clio)



  Peugeot 207 GT THP
The website seems to be down at the moment. I've got the current mag in work which has the results in it. From what I can remember though the Clio didn't do too well. It was definitely placed well over 100.
 
  05 Plate MG ZR 105 Trophy
As long as its not in the last ten...

Its pretty bad though as like they said on Top Gear there are 10 french cars in the last 13 (most were Peugeot's, I think).
 
  Yaris Hybrid
As you saw from the programme, many people with low rated cars reported having no problems so I wouldn't worry about where your car comes in an owner satisfaction survey as I feel the results can be a little distorted at times as there are motives involved.

My friend kept his S2000 for all of a few months....and ditched it for a Renault. What does that say about satisfaction? He didn't complete the survey though, perhaps the bald, boring, sterile, middle aged men that drive Honda's were the only ones that replied.
 
  Ford Fiesta
reason i didnt ask on the show was cos I thought it'd be low. I know he likes the RS clios but on the survey a clio is just a clio.
 
  850 T5. mmmm Turbo!
well id have mine at the bottom, its the worst car i have ever owned, the best on paper, and economy but full of problems, and the worse customer service out there.
even though renault keep coming at the bottom, they still dont do anything about it, so the servey is just a waste of time IMO!
 
Harry_manback said:
even though renault keep coming at the bottom, they still dont do anything about it

thats because people still keep buying them.

As long as there is a demand, they have no need to do anything about it.
 
  Yaris Hybrid
I think at the end of the day people know that they get what they pay for. French cars are at the bottom but they are also amongst the cheapest and thats with the some of the highest levels of standard kit.

You can tell someone that a Lexus is more reliable and they would probably believe you but still go out and buy a French car. Quite why they then go and sl*g it off in a satisfaction survey because bits fall off I don't know. The £5k or whatever you save on the price should be adequate compensation for having to drive a 1.2 courtesy car for a few days whilst your car is being fixed for free under the warranty.
 
  850 T5. mmmm Turbo!
Toypop said:
I think at the end of the day people know that they get what they pay for. French cars are at the bottom but they are also amongst the cheapest and thats with the some of the highest levels of standard kit.

You can tell someone that a Lexus is more reliable and they would probably believe you but still go out and buy a French car. Quite why they then go and sl*g it off in a satisfaction survey because bits fall off I don't know. The £5k or whatever you save on the price should be adequate compensation for having to drive a 1.2 courtesy car for a few days whilst your car is being fixed for free under the warranty.

thats crap, it really is, if u buy a car whatever the price bits should NOT fall off, we should NOT accept a car thats faulty, if you buy a cheep cooker, would you be ok eating takeaway if i breaks down once a month???

No is the answer, but for some reason people buy them and accept their faults, and live with a courtesy car, its a break from peoples daily routines going to the reno garage, and if thats true its f**king sad!
 
  Clio 182
Clio came 125th :/ let down by Customer Care (No surprise there), Comfort, Squeaks/Rattles (Again no surprise), Fit/Finish, Engine/Gearbox & ReliabilityElectrical Reliability.
 
  mk1 172
Its sad when it gets beaten by a Kia Rio in all honesty!!

Would have been nice to seperate the RS from the non RS to see if it might have come any higher?
 

al

  ST on the way...
Dave_W said:
Its sad when it gets beaten by a Kia Rio in all honesty!!


Would have been nice to seperate the RS from the non RS to see if it might have come any higher?

Very much doubt it!
 
  BMW E46 330i Touring
Hmm, check out the number of stars the Megane (152) picks up compared to the 206 (151... 1 place better). The Megane appears to have a better average but has been placed below the Pug.

With these things, the model as a whole is always going to finish low, French cars just aren't very good on the whole, compared to the leaps that German, Jap and even English manufacturers have made recently. An RS-only survey would probably see it perform marginally better, but probably not that much considering you would then have to include all the sport derivatives from all the manufacturers...

Who cares? Me? No, I love my car, rattles 'n' all. :)
 
Toypop said:
As you saw from the programme, many people with low rated cars reported having no problems so I wouldn't worry about where your car comes in an owner satisfaction survey as I feel the results can be a little distorted at times as there are motives involved.

My friend kept his S2000 for all of a few months....and ditched it for a Renault. What does that say about satisfaction? He didn't complete the survey though, perhaps the bald, boring, sterile, middle aged men that drive Honda's were the only ones that replied.
Sorry I disagree with you. We have an S2000 and a 182 Cup. I'm not bald, boring etc and neither is my missus. The S2000 is a fantastic car - just make sure you take the cod liver oil when getting in and out of the car.
 


Top