I'm in the same boat, i've read too many comments on tyres and i'm more uncertain as what to buy than ever.
I need 2 new tyres and i've got a budget of £50 a tyre, and as soon as I think i've found a good one where all the comments are good,
I find a comment saying they won't grip in the wet, or the sidewalls are soft, or I ended up in a ditch etc.
I think asking on here is a pain in the arse sometimes.