Pearcy that mini is worth nothing anyway. All r/h suspension would probably write it off!
The lotus would have required a rear clamshell so it would be a straight forward write off.
I don't care particularly what the guy 'thinks looks like a write off', the fact is that on an R27 a metal quarter panel, boot lid, bumper, light, wheel, stub, and glass:
a) Isn't £5-6k.
b) Isn't minor rear quarter damage.
As you've said the Mini's worth a fiver and cosmetics rarely write 'normal' cars off. The Aston, so it's got a crack on a panel which goes up to the roof - that's got to be expensive, plus if it was under a year old and first owner the owner will have got a spanker - what happens to their car (gally, you may be able to answer this!), is it written off?
The Lotus is at least a rear clam as Gally said, and you're looking at the steep side of £10k from what I can remember of the sales guy telling me I really, really didn't want to crash mine.
^What about the DB9? It doesnt 'look' that bad! lol
As above, maybe gally can shed some light on first year bumps and write offs and new cars and whatnot.