Capturing packets in Wireshark is not going to give away anything regarding the contents of the call. Your conversations aren't transmitted over the network as plain text you know.
That said, if the packets could be captured it must be possible to piece them back together somehow, even if it means replaying them across the wire to a target handset.
If it's a VOIP system they've had installed, they'll need something like Cisco VOIP Monitor Server or the one from NetIQ (forgot it's name). These are probably your best option.
Cisco Desktop Administrator can also record calls, should you wish to use that instead.