I had a set of Toyo T1R's on my FRS and they were really good. They had more grip in the wet than my original Michelin Pilot Sports had in the dry. The Eagles are good also, we use them on our works cars and grip well and last long.
It is really down to personal choice. Some people slate the Toyo's and like me, I rate them. If you like the tyres that were on the car, then I would probably just get another set of them put on. Less hassle, as there are that many different tyres with manufactures claiming that their tyres are the best etc and blinding us with facts and figures.