It depends on what your after as to what is deemed 'best' imo.
If you can live without your creature comforts such as air con etc which a full fat 172 comes with (I certainly can) then imo you should go for a Cup. They are rarer than a full fat 172 but with this comes the fact they generally tend to have a bigger premium than a normal 172. If you do like a car with these features and its mainly used for daily commuting then go for the normal 172.
They are both great cars but i like the fact that cups are 'special' and are a 'raw' experience of the RS 1*2.
Things to looks out for; belts change, servicing, knocks from the suspension components, all of the usual things when checking a car over really.