ClioSport.net

Register a free account today to become a member!
Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read more here.

172 suspension knocking



Lee

  BMW M2C


Yesterday I left my car with my local dealer at 8am in the morning, giving them more than enough time to deal with the 5 things I wanted looking into.

These being, in order of importance:

Knocking from the suspension when cornering
Passenger seat runners loose (again)
Vibration from the centre of the dash
Steering off centre
Choppy running when cold

Out of the 5 the first two were the ones I actually cared about, but while it was there I figured Id get the lot looked at.

At 3pm yesterday they called to say they couldnt find any of the faults and I could I explain how to replicate them. Which I did. (Why wait till so late to look at my car). Anyway, they replaced some bits on the nearside suspension hoping to have cured the knock. When I collected the car, the seat runners had been done, and the knock cured.

Driving home, the seat is fine, the car feels positively German built without that rattle! But the knocking is still there.

So......this morning I went back and explained its still doing it. The service manager came out with me, and the first corner I came to I get it to knock (I also draw his attention to the dash vibration), he doesnt seem surprised, what with it being a known fault on 172/Cups. Unfortunately, mine has now been repaired twice, but the repair not taken.

After some sweet talking from me they have taken the car back today to have a go at fixing it again. If they fail there is nothing else they can do but ask Renault UK for help. All they can do is apply the fixes they are given.

Fingers crossed its sorted this time.

At least my exhaust goes on tomorrow, that should at cheer me up.

Just thought Id waste 5 minutes typing this.

Lee
 

Lee

  BMW M2C


Quote: Originally posted by D-CUP on 17 October 2003

Lets face it, this suspension knock seems to uncureable.
Im not giving up yet. Its only been a problem on the newer ones so what have they changed?
 


It seems like Renault appointments run like doctors appointments.

You wait for bloody ages in the waiting room, they then give you a set time to be looked at, if they dont fix your problem in that time they fob you off and you have to start all over again with another appointment which carrys on where the last one ended, so eventually you get it sorted....
 

Lee

  BMW M2C


As far as Im concerned they can remove it if it helps mike.

Magnex cat back system Chris.

I got it "looked at" a few weeks ago Viv. I phoned and said I felt unsafe in it, and they agreed to give it the once over.

Still no word from them yet!!
 

Lee

  BMW M2C


They have "re carried out the mod and fitted new suspension top mounts". Im off to fetch it.

I wonder if they have bothered to test drive it to see if its actually fixed it this time!
 


Same problem on mine mate, various complaints to Reno UK about the fact the built the car as if it was 3pm on a Friday.

Still go the knock too after various replacement parts- they had the cheek to claim it was mabyes part of the design & within tolerance- b&satrds!!!
 

Ad

  MK2 FRS


lol, I gave them four things yesterday, the spent 8.5hrs on the one fault, the 4k rattle, not solved and didnt have time to look at anything else.

Im now waiting for renault uk to send a technical person out at there convienence, i must ensure the car is at the dealers on the date they decide else they wont look after it.

Still got the knocking on suspension, leather coming off the gear knob, and drivers light that points downwards....The joys of being a 172 owner.
 


Our MK1 has just started with the knocking suspension. My 2000 1.4 16v did it and my MK2 172 did it.

Edit - irritating, isnt it......
 


my 172 had a knock turnred out it was the engine mount had worked loose the one under the battery bit of a faff to get to but cured the knock
 

Lee

  BMW M2C


Ive got the car back. They have re done the mod and replace parts of the suspension strut tops again.

The service manager reckons he couldnt get the knock to happen but did say I may stand more chance the way I probably drive. And I took it easy when he was in the car this morning.

Im sure I got it to knock a couple of times on the way home this eveing, but Ill know for sure tomorrow when I drive to Wales. Good job they are a nice friendly bunch at Sutton Park Renault, as I seem to be there a fair bit at the moment. Theyve been really helpful, but there is only so much they can do when the car is so badly built!

The service guy even joked yesterday I may have a Friday afternoon car. I said it must be Thursday as the engine/gearbox/clutch are holding up so far!!
 


Top