Ok, so I played this for a fair few hours last night. First impression are that it looks EPIC, like seriously nice. With a Premium car on a new track, it's stunning. Going back to Forza 3 later, online, was like a step back in time.
Also, the menus are brilliant and the music is awesomely Japanese. <3
The replays are a thing of beauty. With a Premium car, they could be real! Gobsmacking. The Premium EK9 I used was giving me the horn.
But... (you knew this was coming)
THe graphics of the Standard cars are below par. The shut lines are just drawn on, like in GT4. The shading and reflections are a mess (sometimes the whole car is one big mirror for a few seconds). The pre-race shots of the car look terrible on them, too. The EK9 and S2000, to name a few, have a flickering shadow under the door mirrors almost constantly. :dapprove:
The sound of the cars is terrible. An EK9 sounds like a blender, and the R8 V8 sounds so digitised it's a joke. As do many others. No real surprise, as GT games have never been strong in this area.
The handling is 95% identical to Prologue. Epic understeer in 9/10 cars, regardless of drivetrain, then swapping to snap oversteer quicker than you can say 'I hate this pad' ...Gutted. :dapprove:
The damage is better than I thought, if I'm honest. The Standard cars only scuff and scrape, which is a bit sh*t, but not a deal breaker. The Premiums deform pretty well, but it takes a full-on, 100mph head-on collision to get a dent. Not great.
Then there's the AI. Oh, the AI. Or lack thereof. It's just not good enough, end of. If you spin out, other cars will just mindlessly pile into you without braking or flinching. They'll also keep accelerating into you if you're blocking their path. They're that dim-witted. Again, not great.
It'll sell in millions, and be declared a success because of that. But IMO, it's a hastily updated GT4 with amazing visuals on 1/5th of the cars. Not something you'd expect after six years of development.
I've owned every GT game, sinking hundreds of hours into them, and I held onto my PS3 for this title, so don't tar me with the 'Forza Fanboy Brush' because I wanted this to be as good as it should've been.