I just spent like an hour looking for materials on 3 or 4 planets with a scanner, boring and I can't even find what I'm supposed to do with them.
The gunfights are ok but it's nothing amazing. It's like Halo 3 but with much more boring speaking bits and not quite as good combat. I really don't see what the hype is about now I've got into it a bit more. It was alright when I started out and did a few mission but now it's just speak speak speak, shoot, speak speak speak, shoot. It's too slow moving, you'll probably get your moneys worth out of it because it will last literally a lifetime
Games like Forza 3, H3 (even though it's old now), MW2 stand out as great games that I recommend to people when they ask but won't do the same for this. Haven't had a try of borderland yet even though I got it when it came out. Maybe that will stand up to the hype