Sony Ericsson X1 vs Sony Ericsson C905

[DazG]

Good afternoon ladies

Which one would you choose?

http://www.gsmarena.com/compare.php3?idPhone2=2427&idPhone1=2246

I have an upgrade with Vodafone on the 21st October and these phones happen to be coming out round about the same time.

In the past I have always gone for a camera phone but I fancy something different so do I go for the top spec 8mp C905 or the windows mobile based X1?

Any thoughts?

 

[Tom]

Neither. Both shite.

Reasoning:

A200 is a crap OS (Ask K850 owners)
WinMob 6.1 is the oldest operating system known to man and is rubbish, however the x1 looks nice.

 

[DazG]

I currently have the K850 I don't think its too bad but it could be a lot of better.

X1 does look good and does have a good spec, do you reckon its a good alternative to the IPhone?

 

[Tom]

No. The BB storm and G1 are good iphone rivals.

Anything winmob is just a pretty 5 year old device.

 

[DazG]

:dapprove: That sounds rather dissappointing!

I might still take a trip to a vodafone shop and try them out when they get released.

 

[Tom]

The panel software on the x1 is interesting, but its a thinly disguised gimmick

http://www.engadgetmobile.com/2008/02/10/video-sony-ericssons-xperia-x1-panel-interface/

The nokia 5800 tube is out this week too.

 

[DazG]

Never been a fan of Nokia's styling and software, not to my taste!

 

[Ian_182]

Tom ,whats the best phone at the moment for general everyday use.Me and the wife are both due free upgrades.She likes the n96 by the way and i like se

 

[JJ!]

Pretty sure my w890i is A200 platform and its been pretty much faultless.

 

[coxy777]

C905 runs a newer system anyway, A200 with bits on top.

 

[Saner]

Tom, When is the next flagship Walkman phone out? and will it be any good?

Also when you going to reply to my PM

 

[Ian_182]

Has tom kieled over

 

[Tom]

No i just decided to go outside for a bit.