My cup runs noticably better on Optimax 98ron than regular 95. Both Throttle response and feels quicker generally, pulling through the rev range quicker(possibly better torque). Not talking massive amounts here but I think it's worth the difference. Whats the point in buying a performance car if your not going to get the best out of it.
BP I think take the pi** for charging more for their super unleaded when it's a lower grade fuel (97).
There's a reason why it say's 98 only on the inside of the filler.
Try running on the cheap stuff for a while then go back to Optimax, I think you might notice it more.