The Eurogamer review is really interesting. They "only" give it 8/10.
Most games should get an 8. Even the exceptional ones. It gives something to improve upon. Saying that, it's not doing too badly elsewhere...
IGN - 10/10
"Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception is the reason I play video games."
"So exceptional that it is hard to imagine a game being better"
Official PlayStation Magazine – 10/10
“A game that can claim to not only be the best on PS3, but also one of the best in gaming history...Uncharted 3 is incredible and God only knows how this can ever be improved on"
“A masterpiece of modern gaming”
Empire - 5/5
"The definitive PlayStation 3 title worth stuffing in your stocking this Christmas."
Zoo - 10/10
"This year's greatest adventure"
"Drake is back and he's kicking ass like never before"
Metro - 9/10
"An interactive roller-coaster of outstanding ambition, technical ability, and genuine heart."
The Telegraph - 4.5/5
"Drakes Deception further entrenches Nathan Drake as this generations Indiana Jones, in this gorgeous thrilling adventure"
PSM3 - 96%
"Uncharted 3 does action on a scale PS3 – gaming – has not seen before."
CVG - 9.5/10
"An absolute must-have."
Gametrailers - 9.5/10
"Shouldn't be missed"
TheSixthAxis – 10/10
“There hasn’t been a better Single Player game for years”
IncGamers - 10/10
"A landmark achievement for this generation"
NextGenGamingBlog -10/10
"A masterclass in video games design and storytelling"
"Not only one of the best games that you’ll play this year, it’s one of the best games of its generation full stop."
Nowgamer - 9.7/ 10
"It’s a gigantic success; moment after moment of breathtaking action, epic adventuring, grand vistas and superlative set pieces.