Ive been tempted by a 200 several times, new car appeal, but id never sell my 172ph2(none cup) at the moment, the 200 is all well and good but if your a person who likes to "mod" cars like me....i couldnt leave it alone, thus costing a bomb for the new parts and upgrades. Plus! i wouldnt want to drive it very hard like do my 172, (it really does get some serious stick now its pretty heavily modded) as id be worrying about stone chips and all those paint related things that HAVE to happen to new cars lol, nothing stays mint if you drive it. Once it gets a bit shabby all over paint wise, you kinda of relax on the paint side and except it, but on a new car its a whole bunch of hurt for the first few years lol.
You reallly cant beat a ph1/ph2 clio for thrills per £ in IMO, ive spent about 4 grand on upgrades to mine, which is about 2.5x what the cars worth, as its high miler (all my miles lol). The paints shabby, it doesnt get cleaned that often, and its completely stripped out so looks pretty bad inside (apart from my nice buckets), but in the twists it never fails to keep me coming back for more. I dont really buy cars for a badge or for show, i buy them to drive them as hard as safely possible on the track and spirited drives on the road, if your buying a car for show then a 200 is a decent choice in the £ bracket, but you should drive it it for show lol and thats something i cant do lol, id have to put my stamp on it, "function over form".
This is how sure i am , im keeping my clio, i have a 26k F4R engine sat on a stand waiting for when this baby blows, she'll be "Spray Shack" branded over the winter, and tracked next year.
Just my two penneth,