The best computer game I've played... Dungeon Master (on the Atari ST, for those old enough to remember it). It kept me hooked for aaaaaaaaaages and I loved it. Great map design, great spell system, great character development, good blend of enemies.
The best console game I've played... Super Mario World (on the SNES). The most perfect and rewarding run and jump platformer ever made. Pure gaming Heaven.
Ah. You had it on the ST. Us 'poor' Amiga owners had to foot the extra £65 or so for the 512k memory upgrade! But yep, it was an awesome game. My m8 completed it many times - even trying it with just one character (Stamm the dwarf, iirc) and managing it. FTL means something completely different on here, but FTL to me is one of the iconic developers of games. Such as shame that their product range was literally a flash-in-the-pan.
For me, it is without doubt
Wasteland from 1988 by Electronic Arts & Interplay. Played on the Commodore 64 via 5.25" disks it was truly an epic RPG game. The grand-daddy of the current
Fallout series - it gave you the scope to wander, interact and develop your characters; all on a computer with the processing power of a current day watch. In gaming terms, it was like flying the Wright Brothers' flyer - then being give the SR-71 to pilot. A complete paradigm shift in capabilities.
Since then, I've looked into the coding of how Wasteland worked (yes, sad I know) - but those programmers were nothing short of geniuses. In such limited memory space, they allowed random and calculated events to flourish whilst containing such a varied and enjoyable gaming environment.
Truly a benchmark in gaming. Certainly from the RPG perspective.
D.