Easy decision for me. I don't want no 1st, 2nd or 3rd place, just simply YOUR all time favourite game ever, past or present.
Mine?
Half Life. I don't even need to explain why...
GoldenEye
The best computer game I've played... Dungeon Master (on the Atari ST, for those old enough to remember it). It kept me hooked for aaaaaaaaaages and I loved it. Great map design, great spell system, great character development, good blend of enemies.
The best console game I've played... Super Mario World (on the SNES). The most perfect and rewarding run and jump platformer ever made. Pure gaming Heaven.
Are the MW crowd of a younger generation? I can't fathom how any COD game could be ranked so highly over some of the older games that have been mentioned.
Older games weren't online.The older games were of course good, but always got bored of playing them at some point. I've played nothing else more than MW2