Due to the odd scrapes etc i agree with others and would say it wouldn't fall into the 'Mint' catagory but if the service history and mileage are all adding up ok then it seems like a fairly good example (personally not £3000 good).
I know i am slightly biased but i don't think you can compare Ph1's to Ph2's when it comes to cost, i know the ph2's are newer etc but i would imagine that the reason for buying a Ph1 over a ph2 (majority of Ph1 owners) is personal preference, prefer the drive/style etc - my reason is simple... i think it looks better it's only about a year older than alot of the Ph2's so why should it be worth like a grand or more less?
Often its more desirable and desirability counts most