Love peoples understanding of the modern AMT (Automatic manual transmission). Its the complete lack of understanding that makes people have a bad time with them. For example I keep reading people barking about it not having a clutch... Well it does...but you wont control it. If people drove these boxes remembering that there is a clutch in there and used a bit of mechanical sympathy they actually become very smooth and very enjoyable to use. And as for knocking the VW DSG... mental statement. I drove a v6 TT with the DSG and it was bloody fantastic, going from 6th to 3rd with a few flicks of my L1 finger (playstation pad) in a mater of seconds was phenomenal.. If I could choose a manual H gate or an AMT on track I know which one I would choose.
We are going to have to put up with AMT's and smaller turbo engines because of CO2 ratings and what not, at the end of the day if you want a raw Renault driving experience buy a PH1.. or better still a Willy.
I know an AMT 'box is better in almost every way, that's not disputed...it's the interaction that's lacking.
Clicking a button or pulling a paddle does not come close to the sensation of a perfectly rev matched downshift while braking and entering. It's a skill that's pleasurable to perform
I'm no racing driver, nor do I consider myself a particularly fast driver, but that sums it up for me. I enjoy using three pedals. I enjoy rev matching and h&t. That to me is all part of the driving experience.
Unfortunately this seems to be the way the motor industry is heading. Will the manual box will soon be a thing of the past, like the choke? (i'm not old enough to have used one of those!)
Unfortunately this seems to be the way the motor industry is heading. Will the manual box will soon be a thing of the past, like the choke? (i'm not old enough to have used one of those!)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but surely a manual 6 speed box will be cheaper to produce and fit into every model? I thought this was what Renault were trying to do, in terms of keeping manufacturing costs down through 5 door only etc?
Don't get me wrong I ain't having a go, I know and understand the interaction and its all part of the joy of driving. Perhaps its as I am getting old, or it might be the several botched down shifts and subsequent brown trouser moments i had when i was at the "Ring" not so long ago. I really don't mind the idea of the AMT.
you are right too but the easy increase of the power by mod the pression in the turbo the Turbo is not a good thing in a middle or long period for the rest of the engine...
Left foot braking is pretty simple tbh, using two pedals with one foot is what I and it seems everyone else here likes doing, it is just more pleasurable.
I'm probably not as good a driver on here then.