Are the Tip tronic's really that bad? My dad's got one on his 997 and he took me for a quick blast on the weekend, after he got it back from having some suspension work done and it seemed to work well with the car. Far enough it's no PDK and you don't get paddles but rather buttons on the steering wheel instead.
Are they unreliable/ have their fair share of problems? I'm not sure i could have a manual one if it was me, But, then again, i'm coming round to the idea of automatics now, which never really used to be the case. I suppose, if they are notorious for faults, it's just one thing else to worry about going wrong.