I want to join in, so here's the Golf I had for a year:
View attachment 1571175View attachment 1571176View attachment 1571177
Extremely capable, but not really involving enough for my tastes. I do really rate the MK7 Golf overall, but would probably have a manual GTI PP if I had another, or an Edition 40 if I could find one in the right spec.
Not driven the Cupra, but I replaced the above Golf with a Megane 265 and it felt like a racing car by comparison. Way, way, way more focused and involved to drive. I think a FWD, manual Cupra would be closer to the Meg, but I'd be amazed if it was as fun/engaging to drive. Probably a better every day car, as the interior and infotainment is a bit nicer, but Renault absolutely nailed the 250/265/275 as a driving tool.
I don't think either has a particularly outstanding engine. The EA888 is "better" in that it's more responsive, but it's pretty dull feeling as standard, as it's very linear. The Megane isn't quite so responsive, but the bit of lag gives it a bit more character. Mid box chop makes it come alive a bit more as it adds some theatre. Both are effective enough, but not that memorable.